Psychological egoism and selfinterest reason papers. Because psychological egoism states that every act of every person is motivated by selfinterest, it is universal. Psychological egoism is implies an important truth that is often obscured in moral discourse, namely, that pure altruism is an impossible ideal. Psychological egoism is the thesis that we are always deep down motivated by what we perceive to be in our own selfinterest. Psychological egoism 449 further reading canovan, margaret. Psychological egoism is the view that humans are always motivated by selfinterest, even in what seem to be acts of altruism. Feinbergs critique psychological egoism view that all.
Joel feinberg joel feinberg 19262004 was professor of philosophy at the university of arizona. Joel feinberg psychological egoism pdf download download joel feinberg psychological egoismjoel feinberg psychological egoism pdfjoel feinberg psychological egoism articlejoel feinberg psychological egoism essayjoel feinberg psychological egoism summary 0fea0b1dc0 a specific form of psychological egoism is psychological hedonism. John clarke of hulls argument for psychological egoism. Psychological egoism and its critics mercer 1998 the. Psychological egoism and its critics, the southern journal. Psychological egoism is a claim about all intentional actions. We always seek to maximize our own self interest psychological egoism 2. Feinberg studied at the university of michiganwriting his dissertation on the philosophy of the harvard professor ralph barton perry under the supervision of charles stevenson. Altruistic acts involve putting others interests ahead of your own altruism 4. The beliefs on egoism in relation to human behavior. The paper ends with numerous quotations from feinbergs vast array of writings, words that express his ideas on a number of important. So far as he can tell, there are four primary arguments for it. Feinberg and rachels both play fast and loose with these distinctions. Among the subjects that have been part of it is the topic about psychological egoism vs.
Feinberg psychological egoism pdf psychological egoism is the doctrine that the only thing anyone is capable of desiring or pursuing ultimately is. In other chapters, feinberg is too analytical and often unclear. A simple counterexample to psychological egoism would be when people sacrifice themselves for others like stopping a bullet. Psychological egoism is the view that humans are always motivated by selfinterest and. The second volume in joel feinberg s series the moral limits of the criminal law, offense to others focuses on the offense principle, which maintains that preventing shock, disgust, or revulsion is always a morally relevant reason for legal prohibitions. Pojman, a critique of ethical egoism joel feinberg, psychological egoism the formula looks familiar. Tilley 2015 british journal for the history of philosophy 23 1. The egoist says that all of us are necessarily selfregarding. What are rachels arguments against the view that all acts are done for selfinterest. Psychological egoism is a theory that holds that human beings always behave selfishly in everything that they do, and that it is impossible for them to behave otherwise.
What are the three common confusions about psychological. It says, roughly, that human beings are so constituted as to. According to joel feinberg there are some points that have made psychological. Because psychological egoism states that all motivations are, in the final analysis, selfish, it is reductive. Joel feinberg october 19, 1926 in detroit, michigan march 29, 2004 in tucson, arizona was an american political and legal philosopher. Part ii the question about the validity of the argument from psychological egoism to ethical egoism, then, comes to. Psychological egoism is roughly the thesis that our actions are always ultimately. Suppose, for example, that pam saves jim from a burning office building.
Psychological egoism psychological egoism is the thesis that we always act from selfish motives. But the psychological egoist holds that pams apparently altruistic act is ultimately motivated by the goal to benefit. The bloomsbury encyclopedia of utilitarianism editor james e. Psychological egoism elliott sober psycliological egoism is a theory about motivation that claims that all of our ulti mate desires are selfdirected. Psychological egoism internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Here the ought is not restricted to the moral ought. What is feinberg s point in telling the story about abraham lincoln. If one derives satisfaction from helping others, does it make one selfish. Psychological egoism psychological egoism, whose proponents include epicurus, hobbes, spinoza, and arguably bentham, and whose critics include butler, hume, and sidgwick, is a doctrine about human nature, and speci. Mark mercer is an unaffiliated philosopher with a ph.
Psychological egoism project gutenberg selfpublishing. Every action can be explained by appealing to selfinterest, even if this requires that we appeal to unconscious motivations. A recent defense of a form of psychological egoism that appeals to introspection and the purported unintelligibility of altruistic explanations of actions. Psychological altruism, on the other hand, is the view that sometimes we can have ultimately altruistic motives. Psychological egoism is a descriptive theory that rather than suggesting, as ethical or rational egoism does, how people ought to live, suggests how people actually go about their lives. You are touching on something called psychological egoism. Distinguish psychological egoism from ethical egoism. Psychological egoism is the thesis that we always act from selfish motives. Only the two chapters on criminal law theorypunishment are worth reading for feinberg provides a concise summary of his moral limit of criminal law project. Of particular interest to me is the paradox of hedonism. It must be distinguished from the normative claim that.
Joel feinberg psychological egoism pdf what is psychological egoism, and how does it differ from ethical egoism. Whenever we want others to do well or ill, we have these otherdirected desires only instrumentally. Psychological egoism vs ethical egoism flow psychology. The theory of psychological egoism and ethical egoism essay 1039 words 5 pages. I enjoyed reading the text in my undergraduate class this semester and recommend it to anyone that is taking a philosophy of law class at their undergrad university. Joel feinberg, in his 1958 paper psychological egoism, embraces a similar critique by. Psychological egoism is the view that people are always selfish. Joel feinberg delineated principles for reconciling opposing views regarding permissible grounds for interference with someones actions for the sake of preventing harm. The argument from psychological egoism to ethical egoism. Most of you reading this will know joel feinberg only as the editor of a book youve been. Clearly, then, they would not be doing it because it feels good, since they will be dead. Psychological egoism is the view that humans are always motivated by selfinterest and selfishness, even in what seem to be acts of altruism.
Joel feinberg psychological egoism psychological egoism in a paper prepared in 1958 for the benefit of students at brown, feinberg seeks to refute the philosophical theory of psychological egoism, which in his opinion is fallacious. Psychological egoism, as we discussed it, is the view that every person acts, ultimately, only for selfish reasons joel feinberg rejects psychological egoism on the grounds that. A more commonly held subset of this belief is psychological egoistic hedonism, which says that we only act for our own pleasure. It holds that all desires are egoistic desires, or else derived egoistic desires. Psychological egoism theory essay 2108 words bartleby. The first section of the paper applies feinbergs analysis of freedom of expression to a contemporary case of academic freedom. What do you think is the best argument in favor of the theory. Psychological egoism by joel feinberg philosophercharlie. The theory of psychological egoism refers to the view that all human actions are selfcentered. What is psychological egoism, and how does it differ from ethical egoism. Egoism argues that not only ought one to pursue ones own interests but, that caring for others is ethically rejected unless one assigns selfvalue to the action. Acclaimed both for his groundbreaking scholarship and his exemplary teaching skills, feinberg published widely on topics such as individual rights, legal theory, capital punishment, the.
Psychological egoism and selfinterest william irwin kings college, wilkesbarre, pa 1. It claims that, when people choose to help others, they do so ultimately because of the personal benefits that they themselves expect to obtain, directly or indirectly, from doing so. Psychological egoism this is from guest blogger, michael dean. An essential feature of any explanation is testability, but what could ever count as a counterexample to psychological egoism. Psycholo many peopl the followin joel feinberg psychological egoism the theory 1. Psychological egoism philosophy paper psychological egoism is the view that people are always selfish.
The history about the psychological egoism philosophy essay. Terms in this set 88 according to our definition of an argument, in an argument the. With these points in mind, we can characterize egoistic and altruistic desires in the psychologidal way although actions may vary in content, the ultimate source is selfinterest. Introduction in this article i defend an unpopular, some might say discredited, position. The opening argument he dubs a tautology from which nothing whatever concerning the nature of my motives or the objective of my desires can possibly follow. According to the merge with others hypothesis, empathy increases the more an. View that all human conduct is selfishly motivated. Introduction to psychological egoism tracy kline this selection is part of a larger article that appeared on the original sophia project in 2000.
Do you agree with the verdict he draws from the story. Psychological egoism is the view that humans are always motivated by self interest and. Joel feinberg bibliography compiled by keith burgess. Jan, 2017 3 clearly outline major logical distinctions and 3 main arguments for egoism 4 clearly explain the problem with each argument and why p egoism is probably false 5 explore the scientific.
Joel feinberg presents a multitude of arguments against psychological egoistic hedonism. Jan 01, 1975 a required book for any philosophy of law class in undergrad, the feinberg complication gives the reader a great introduction into the philosophic issues involved in legal theory. An alternate form of psychological egoism, psychological hedonism, relates to jerry benthams ideals, the only kind of desire is the desire to get or to prolong pleasant experiences, and to avoid or cut short unpleasant experiences for oneself feinberg 167. Rachels, humans are not always selfish lander university. Dec 08, 20 psychological egoism is the belief that men only act in selfinterest in all situations, and when we help others we do it for ourselves. Joel feinberg and the justification of hard paternalism richard j. Psychological egoism is the thesis that we are always deep down motivated by what we perceive to be. The assumptive nature of the theory introduces a number of possible avenues for refutation, some of which are very compelling. View notes feinberg s critique from phil 160 at university of kansas. Introduction to psychological egoism sophia project. That is, it reduces what seems to be a plurality or a multiplicity of motives to a single kind. Pdf egoism, empathy, and selfother merging researchgate. Feinberg clarifies psychological egoism and maintains that there are several things wrong with this theory.
Critique of psychological egoism david hume there is a principle, supposed to prevail among many, which is utterly incompatible with all virtue or moral sentiment. Psychological egoism psychological egoism is the doctrine that the only thing anyone is capable of desiring or pursuing ultimately is a. Readings in some basic problems of philosophy, 2nd edn. Psychological egoism is the belief that men only act in selfinterest in all situations, and when we help others we do it for ourselves. He re jected the view that we act only in our own selfinterest. This paper is offered as a tribute to joel feinberg.
This means that ones emotions of compassion and empathy for those less well off than us or those. Joel developed the first edition of this textbook about forty years ago, dissatisfied with existing options, and intent on providing coverage of those areas of philosophy that struck him as deeply important and deserving of every students careful study. Psychological egoism philosophy paper 632 words bartleby. Feinberg observes that such arguments for psychological egoism are rarely mounted on the basis of empirical proof when, being psychological, they very well ought to. He is known for his work in the fields of ethics, action theory, philosophy of law, and political philosophy as well as individual rights and the authority of the state. Psychological egoism and its critics psychological egoism and its critics mercer, mark 19981201 00. Joel feinberg professor emeritus, late of university of arizona was widely recognized as one of americas leading political and social philosophers. It claims that, when people choose to help others, they do so ultimately because of the personal benefits that they themselves expect to obtain, directly or indirectly, from so doing. Arneson university of california, san diego joel feinberg was a brilliant philosopher whose work in social and moral philosophy is a legacy of excellent, even stunning achievement. The second section engages feinbergs work on rights and punishment.
519 449 303 725 934 140 669 294 462 867 939 86 1545 1508 62 547 378 399 249 538 737 1084 831 562 1230 1511 1220 1079 1047 1105 535 106 1214 1287 998 1203 1201 86 1221 517 1297 43 1391